Underhills Crossing Restaurant

heading-glyph-left-yellow

Reviews

heading-glyph-right-yellow

We are humbled and honored that our patrons continue to enjoy the Underhills experience for nearly 30 years.

Underhills Crossing
4.4
Based on 439 reviews
js_loader

Authentic reviews from our patrons

Carmine B.
Carmine B.
1716686035
There is nothing to critique here. We ordered half dozen oysters, hanger steak, while lobster with mussels and clams over a bed of bucatini spaghetti and a softshell crab. For certain a lot of food.My wife and I shared all. They delivered the food already separated on the plates so we didn’t have to partition it. They also brought out the food in the right ordered and adequately spaced out.Our server is Adam(in the photo) he brings an old school service which brings the right mix of entertainment and empathy all wrapped up with an undeniable energy which makes you feel like you have known him for years.The food is perfect combined with Adam, makes this an unprecedented culinary experience.All this carries a premium price tag, but well worth the price.A must go.
John A.
John A.
1715727527
The staff is over and above with service. The food is typical single portions so if you get sides they can add up. Prices are high.
Derby S.
Derby S.
1715044272
I’ve had the pleasure of eating here many times and it gets better every time!The workers there are top notch, menu is always getting upgraded as well as the drinks.If you have not dined at this GREAT bistro you should do so immediately!!!Looking forward to the next time…
Anne
Anne
1712645349
Underhills has always been a favorite of mine and never disappoints. On my most recent visit, enjoyed a delicious brunch in the very lovely outdoor space. Service was outstanding.
gunga011 G.
gunga011 G.
1707157070
This place continues to impress !Firstly, perfection describes the decor and cleanliness!Service, off the charts !The food is just impeccable. The freshness, the obvious attention to detail on every plate is just amazing.
Lori M.
Lori M.
1705677491
What a fantastic meal! Top notch service, super clean, super friendly. Love it!
Christine D.
Christine D.
1704233039
Very elegant decor and beautiful space. The service is very friendly and down to earth to make everyone welcome.
Nicholas R.
Nicholas R.
1701915891
This review is long overdue as my wife and I have been dining here for years. The food, drinks, ambiance, and service are far above par. Kevin is the master bartender accompanied by his charming personality. The wait staff is always on their best game. Danny, the manager, always checks in to ensure that everything is perfect. This is the best spot in the neighborhood and I highly recommend. Cheers!
irina L.
irina L.
1701614019
My friend and I dined at Underhills Crossing in Bronxville yesterday and it was an incredible experience. The staff was warm and friendly, making us feel right at home. The food was a culinary masterpiece, with dishes like the gnocchi with mushrooms and truffles that were simply divine. And let’s not forget about the drinks. The bloody Mary at Underhills Crossing is not your average cocktail. It was a true work of art, with a beautiful presentation that made it almost too pretty to drink. The location had an elegant and inviting ambiance that made the whole experience even more enjoyable. If you’re in Bronxville, I highly recommend checking out Underhills Crossing for a memorable dining experience.Can’t wait to go back.
Taylor
Taylor
1701466436
Adam was our waiter, amazing, such a nice man . Made us feel like we were regulars. Second time there, will definitely make it our new spot!!
Christina F.
Christina F.
1700883604
Tonight was our first time at Underhills Crossing. We arrived without a reservation, yet we were still greeted with enthusiasm and helpfulness. Our server was attentive, thorough and patient. After our meal, we sat at the bar for creative (yet sensible) cocktails while we enjoyed the live piano music. The bartender was also polite and helpful. We look forward to coming back and exploring the menu further. The ambiance alone was worth it!
Asten Morgan J.
Asten Morgan J.
1699987732
Great local vibe. White table cloth spot but don’t let that deter you. It’s not that fancy as you can be comfortable there dressed casually. They do have a decent sized bar and you can sit there. Live music seems to be part of the ambiance both times I’ve been there. They also have a sidewalk extension that’s done nicely and is heated. Once the temperature drops I’m not sure if that’ll be open but it’s a nice option especially if you don’t have reservations. On that note I’d certainly recommend making reservations especially on the weekends.The staff is attentive and very nice. Most importantly the food is good. They have specials in addition to their regular menu items. Whether you are vegan or a meat eater I think you’d find something to fill your needs.
Ellen S.
Ellen S.
1699136620
Victor our server was on point! Brunch was delicious, enjoyable get together with friend.
Rahul C.
Rahul C.
1697044855
We had a great birthday dinner at Underhills Crossing. The service and the ambience was top notch. Danny, Alfredo, and Elena made the whole experience so special us. Mike was lovely on the piano as well.We had the scallops and the cascatelli pasta and both were delicious.Underhills Crossing is a culinary treasure for the town of Bronxville and I am so impressed by the consistently high standards of hospitality it holds. Compliments to the owner, the chef and the kitchen staff, and the rest of the management team!
Michael B.
Michael B.
1696446038
Had an amazing swordfish cooked to perfection. Service food and atmosphere were all top notch. Piano music made the perfect ambiance.
chalooter
chalooter
1696196632
A great place for dinner. It’s a bit on the pricey side, but you’ll get your money’s worth. Attentive service for sure. Busier on weekends. Large outdoor heated space and live piano music. Nice atmosphere and dining room. You start with sliced bread with olive oil, lentils, and chipped parmesan cheese, which is a nice touch. We had tuna tartar and a frisee salad for appetizers that were ample sized and good quality. Entrees were rack of lamb that was 4 meaty chops and a rock shrimp risotto that was out of this world. It came topped with king caviar, which is less salty than most. Dessert was a creme brulee and coffee. Street parking, handicap accessible.
Cindy B
Cindy B
1694832588
Went to this restaurant for the first time tonight and have to say how incredible the ambiance and service was! We sat outdoors and just loved the decoration and how cozy/warm it was. Giovanni was our server and he was absolutely FaNtAsTiC!! He was attentive and really made us feel special! Would visit again for sure!!!
Loren B.
Loren B.
1694705836
I stopped by Underhills on a Saturday afternoon. Since I was alone, I sat at the bar. After a cocktail, and my favorite Lobster Bisque, Adam leaned over and suggested the one of the specials…the Cavatelli Pasta; a dish with a brilliant, light silantro based tomato sauce, homemade lamb sausage, topped with mozzarella. Wow! I learned how a marriage of tastes can make eating a meal fun and educational experience.What was so “educational” about it? For those of us who have eaten lamb, we know that lamb can have…well…a lamb taste. Sure, there are ways to mute the taste, but what if you embraced it? That’s what this dish did. The character of the lamb was intact but blended with the tastes of tomato sauce, silantro, and mozzarella. Each bite was an novel experience. Put very plainly, it was great!If you’re in Bronxville, or you don’t mind a journey, Underhills is a wonderful place to stop in for a great meal and a wonderful experience.
Beverly G.
Beverly G.
1694632144
Brunch was excellent! Sat outside, it rained hard, but was no bother to us under the canopy.
Liz V.
Liz V.
1694278630
You cannot best underhill’s !!! Best of everything! Adam our server was perfect and the other waiters that helped were super helpful!
Angelina H.
Angelina H.
1694183142
I was visiting New York from Colorado having worked in fine dining in Manhattan years earlier.Labor Day 9/4/23 my girlfriend and I were seeking a Bronxville restaurant when we stepped into Underhills Crossing. What first popped out was the lovely decor. But within seconds what clinched the place was being greeted by bartender/server Adam. I spotted immediately that this gentleman knew all about gracious hospitality and that we’d be in good hands.The food is fabulous. The ambiance is great. But to be greeted as if we were old friends is rare.In addition to being attentive to service, Adam was enthusiastic about his food descriptions. My friend and I had a wonderful time! So much so that the next day when I was on my own, I checked to see if Adam was working and took a taxi back to the restaurant to have my last day out on the east coast before flying back to Colorado. Again, I enjoyed the experience immensely.I so wish we had Underhills Crossing in Fort Collins — I’d be first in line to dine there (and locally, I’d tell the world about this fine restaurant) — hands down, the best meal I’ve had this year!
Grace O.
Grace O.
1694047980
Wow this service is unmatched. You have to ask for Danny. He was incredible. Made what was going to be a quick stop a memory and experience.
Ann W.
Ann W.
1693790831
UnderHills Crossing is our FAVORITE spot in Bronxville!!! My husband and I looove this place. Kevin (the bartender) makes the BEST Appletinis!
js_loader