Reviews

Underhills Crossing never disappoints. The Santa Maria Seafood tower had the best, tastiest shrimp and lobster I ever ate. The oysters and clams were fresh and delicious. The bronzino was cooked to perfection and a great portion size. Get the donuts for dessert as they are light and airy. You can tell the staff are true professions as I felt so cared for and catered to. An ultimate dining experience.

We came here for a late brunch and had a pleasant time.

Since it was a nice day, most people were waiting for an outdoor table but we opted for an inside one and we were seated immediately.

Food was great and service was fast. We’re planning on coming back to try their dinner.

My friend and I recently dined at Underhills Crossing on Pondfield Road in Bronxville. The restaurant is quaint yet elegant with a staff that creates an atmosphere of comfort.
The menu is both extensive and flexible. Danny, the Maitre D, took the time to explain the menu in detail. Several dishes are offered as an appetizers or an entree.
Our meal was meticulously served and was delightfully delicious with the accompaniment of live piano music in the background. I had a Soft shell Crab Sautee as my appetizers and the Pan Seared Scallops with a side order of asparagus as my entree. Both appetizers and dinner were everything one would expect while enjoying a fine dining experience.
Underhills Crossing affords its patrons a completely pleasant and most satusfying dining expierience.

A Manhattan dining experience outside of Manhattan. The food is good quality. The atmosphere is nice. Adam is an exceptional server and brings this place to life. Although this place has different options I would recommend the duck and steak tartar.

So classy and fun. Love Kevin the bar tender. Super nice.

This was my fifth visit. Another excellent experience. Highly recommended

Always great!! Always a delight!! If Adam is your server it’s your lucky day!

This review is long overdue. If you are looking for a LUXURIOUS experience look no further. The Underhill Crossing is AMAZING!! There ambiance is CLASSY!! The food is EXCEPTIONAL and their staff is WONDERFUL! This restaurant goes above and beyond for their customers and their service is unmatched. No detail or request is too big for them to fulfill. I have experienced many staff (Axel, Kyra, Roger, Alex, Cesar, Manushka, Adam) to name a few and they were all welcoming and great. Mike the bartender is the best!
Although, I have been here several times I just had a 85th birthday party for my Father and everything was PERFECTION!!
The Underhill Crossing is PHENOMENAL and worth the visit.

We love it here! Service is Michelin star level. Food is outstanding. Drinks are incredible. Great spot for any occasion or a night out!

Great place for a special day. Expensive but worth a splurge.

One of the best restaurants I have ever been to. Amazing piano live, with non stop service from talented and experienced waiters. The food was just phenomenal and was ultimately delicious. I definitely recommend the Escargot 🐌 and Salmon! To anyone reading, you HAVE TO GO!

Had a great meal in a very fun spot. Great ambience and the service was superb

Had a fabulous lunch, everything was perfect. Our waiter Adam was very friendly, attentive and knowledgeable of the menu. I will be back soon.

Food was outstanding and the service was fantastic.
Excellent service by Adam!!!

Exceptional service! Ask for Adam and you’ll quickly be booking your next reservation.

Underhills is always a wonderful experience! Have loved it for years!

Adam was and the staff were excellent as usual 👏

My first visit but not my last. Everything about this restaurant I loved. Our hostess Sophie was fabulous as was our charming waiter.

The staff is over and above with service. The food is typical single portions so if you get sides they can add up. Prices are high. I had one of the best steaks, the powerhouse, in decades. So good

Always a fine meal. Perfect all around, definitely will come back.

Absolutely delicious food, fantastic service, warm environment. Highly recommend!

Eden is the BEST!!!!!!!
We love it here! Food is amazing

This is such an amazing restaurant! Definitely attend when they have live music . They always have delicious specials . I’m never disappointed.

Ambiance is so chic and welcoming! The food is impeccable! Strangolapreti beautifully al dente and the duck was perfection! What made our evening so very special was our server happy smiling Luisa! Wonderfully attentive!

Love!! The food, the service, the atmosphere all 10/10! Will be back

The revamped menu at Underhills Crossing is perhaps their best yet. Last night I had the Barramundi over asparagus risotto that was out of this world. The only other time I tried Barramundi was in its native Australia and this was better.
Manager Danny, the kitchen and wait staff are at the top of their game and owner Steven has created at atmosphere unlike any other in Westchester County. From the moment you walk in, the piano music transforms you to another place and all the worries of the week are put behind. Excellent experience and meal!

This was my second time coming to this place and it was absolutely incredible 💯

We had the tuna tartare which wasn’t exactly what I expected since it was a sweet version of it but it was very nice anyways. The oysters are the best thing on the apps. And we also tried the French onion soup and it was insanely good.

For my main I requested from my server James to have a variation of the salmon and I just ordered a creamy risotto and a salmon with a side of asparagus, everything was excellent !!

The salmon was on point really crusty outside but nice and soft inside and the risotto had the perfect texture and flavor.

For dessert we shared the profiteroles and the tiramisu (this last one is made in front of you at the table). Both delicious.

James didn’t miss a single detail he was very helpful with all our requests and gave us an amazing experience.

Prices are a bit high but totally worth the experience.

By far, my favorite restaurant in Westchester County. Staff is excellent and food is amazing 👏

Service was rather slow but otherwise a nice experience.

Food was exquisite, with large portions, waiters were attentive to our needs, and the neighborhood was very nice, The only issue is parking can be iffy.

Ax and Eric were great. I absolutely recommend this restaurant. I will be back.

We stopped in for the bar. Really upscale place. I felt under dressed. My gf got the passion fruit margarita, I got a bourbon old fashioned. The bartender Genaro made excellent recommendations for a dessert Espresso Affalato. Spelling maybe off I made a video. The staff was courteous and inviting for the most part until their hostess asked another patron to sit outside over a dress code. I’m not one to normally care but I felt as though I was under dressed and for them to even ask someone else to sit outside( which was being set up) . It didn’t affect me , but that wasn’t right. We were there at noon what would be the dress code at that time is beyond me.

The server was a well versed walking menu but the soft shell crabs were the best I’ve ever eaten.

Just wow! Phenomenal service, exquisite food, an all around wonderful experience. We’ve tried different items on the menu and every time we are pleasantly amazed by the quality, creativity and taste of the food. The specials do not disappoint! Elderflower white cosmopolitan is a must!! There’s been a pianist there that plays the times we have dined there which is an added plus! Looking forward to trying the brunch next.